In another installment of the popular “You Can Only Pick 4” series, the guys tackle a common challenge in striped bass surf fishing: choosing the best plugs for shallow water, clear surf, and a bright moon overhead. These certainly aren’t ideal conditions for catching striped bass from the beach, but they’re something every surfcaster encounters throughout the season. So, which four surf fishing plugs would you pack when faced with clear water, shallow structure, and plenty of moonlight? Jerry and Toby reveal their picks and explain why each lure earns a spot in their surf bags. Do you agree with their choices, or did they leave an obvious plug off the list? Let us know!
Discover more from
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

A Larson glider for me in Scott’s wonderbread pattern…
White 9” sluggo with 10/0 weedless hook